|
“I agree with you” is feedback I have often heard after my submission or that of another, in both informal and formal settings. It feels good to hear someone say, “I agree with you,” because, first, it affirms a person. Secondly, as social beings, we naturally enjoy having people on our side.
However, those four words carry with them a risk of deflecting people’s focus from the substance of their submission and, when disagreement arises, forcing them onto the defensive.
Saying “I agree with you” shifts the focus from what has been said to the person who said it because the most powerful word in that sentence is “you.”
To the feedback recipient, it is a response that is primarily not about their argument or proposal. It is about them. It is almost as though the person has presented themselves for assessment and the response is: “I have assessed you, and I agree with you.”
That may seem harmless, but it creates an unnecessary complication.
Consider what happens when the same person makes another submission that you disagree with. What do you say? “I disagree with you.”
Now, again, the focus is perceived to be not on the submission but on the person, and the disagreement can therefore feel personal even when it is not. The person may begin to wonder why you are disagreeing with them when they are still the same person you agreed with before and your relationship dynamics have not changed.
If they have any authority over you, they may consider their position and yours, and question, even without verbalising it, what gives you the right to disagree with them?
If your language consistently makes people, rather than the submission, the object of agreement or disagreement, you risk turning an intellectual discussion into a personal one.
To avoid leading your audience into a personal debate, instead of saying: “I agree with you,” say: “I agree with what you have said.”
Or, even better: “I agree with the submission that has been made.”
The difference may appear subtle, but its impact is far-reaching. With the submission now as the focus of your feedback, if the same person makes a submission with which you disagree, you can simply say:
“I disagree with that submission.”
Here, the person is freed from your assessment because your assessment is directed at their submission, not at who they are. This creates room for healthy disagreement.
When feedback is de-personalised, you invite people to examine the merit in their submissions and ask: “What is it about their argument or proposal that has caused you to agree or disagree?" This distinction is important in workplaces, marriages, families, and any environment where people must regularly exchange ideas, as it creates a much healthier basis for conversation.
Disagree without making people feel rejected. Agree without making people feel personally validated.
Examine ideas, not people. And let your feedback language help people know that.
|